Are Asics and Nike the same size? Shoe sizing guide for runners

Many runners have been there: you order a pair of Asics online, they arrive, and suddenly your toes are squished. Or you grab your usual Nike size, and the shoe feels like a boat. It’s not your feet changing - it’s the brands. Asics and Nike are not the same size. Even if you wear a US 9 in Nike, you might need a US 8.5 or even a full size down in Asics. This isn’t a glitch. It’s how shoe companies design their lasts - the foot-shaped molds they build shoes around.

Why shoe sizes don’t match across brands

Every brand has its own idea of what a size 9 should look like. Nike builds its lasts with a slightly wider forefoot and a more tapered heel. Asics, on the other hand, tends to run longer and narrower, especially in the midfoot. That’s why someone with average-width feet might feel cramped in Asics even if they’ve worn Nikes for years.

It’s not about quality. It’s about fit philosophy. Nike designs for speed and responsiveness - think sprinters and high-tempo runners. Asics focuses on stability and cushioning - ideal for long-distance runners who need support over miles. These goals shape the shape of the shoe.

Look at the numbers. A US men’s size 9 in Nike typically measures about 10.6 inches from heel to toe. In Asics, the same size is closer to 10.8 inches. That half-inch difference might not sound like much, but in a running shoe, it’s enough to make your big toe hit the front of the shoe on downhill runs or cause blisters from heel slippage.

How to find your real size in each brand

Stop guessing. Start measuring.

Take off your socks. Stand on a flat surface with your full weight on one foot. Place a piece of paper against the wall, press your heel against it, and mark the tip of your longest toe. Measure that distance in inches. Do it twice - once in the morning, once at night. Feet swell during the day, and your evening size is what matters for running.

Now compare that number to the official size charts from each brand. Nike’s size chart says a US 9 = 10.6 inches. Asics says a US 9 = 10.8 inches. If your foot is 10.7 inches, you’re right on the edge. In Nike, you’ll likely fit a 9. In Asics, you might need an 8.5 to avoid toe crowding.

Pro tip: Always check the specific model. A Nike Pegasus 40 and a Nike ZoomX Vaporfly NEXT% won’t fit the same. The Pegasus is more generous in the toe box. The Vaporfly is snugger, almost like a racing sock. Same brand, different fit.

Asics vs Nike: real-world fit comparison

Here’s what runners actually experience when switching between these two brands:

• If you wear a US 9 in Nike Pegasus, try a US 8.5 in Asics Gel-Kayano. The Kayano has a roomier heel but a tighter midfoot. You’ll feel like you’re gripping the shoe - good for stability, bad if you have wide feet.
• Go from Nike Air Zoom Structure to Asics GT-2000. The Structure runs true to size. The GT-2000 runs long. You might need to drop half a size.
• Try Nike React Infinity Run. It’s wide in the forefoot. Asics Nimbus is narrower. Even if both are labeled US 10, your toes will feel more space in the Nike.

Women’s sizing adds another layer. Nike’s women’s sizes are cut from the same last as men’s, just scaled down. Asics uses a completely different last for women - narrower heel, higher arch. So if you wear a women’s US 8 in Nike, you might need a women’s US 7.5 in Asics. Don’t assume your men’s size conversion works.

What to do when you can’t try them on

Online shopping is the norm now. But blind buys are risky. Here’s how to reduce returns:

1. Check the product page. Brands like Asics and Nike often list foot length in millimeters. Use that, not the US size.
2. Read reviews. Look for comments like “ran large” or “narrow in the midfoot.” Filter by runners with similar foot shape to yours.
3. Order two sizes. Many retailers allow free returns. Buy your usual size and half a size up. Try them both with your running socks. Walk, jog, hop. See which one feels natural.
4. Use a sizing tool. Apps like Fit Analytics or True Fit let you input your foot measurements and previous shoe brands. They predict the right size across dozens of models.

Don’t rely on Amazon or Zappos size recommendations alone. Their algorithms are trained on returns, not foot anatomy. They’ll tell you to go up a size because 60% of people returned the Nike 9 for being too tight. But if your foot is narrow, you might be in the 40% who fit fine.

What if you have wide feet?

This is where the difference gets serious. Nike offers wide sizes (2E) in most of its running models. Asics does too, but they’re harder to find and often sold out. If you’re a wide-footed runner, Nike is more reliable. The Nike Air Zoom Pegasus Wide, for example, gives you 12mm more width in the forefoot than the standard version.

Asics’ wide models (2E) are great - but they’re designed for runners with high arches and overpronation. If you have flat feet and wide toes, the Asics 2E might still feel too narrow. In that case, go with Nike’s wide version. It’s built for comfort, not correction.

Can you use one brand’s size as a reference for the other?

Yes - but only if you’ve worn both. If you’ve worn a US 9 in Nike for three years and love the fit, start with a US 8.5 in Asics. That’s your baseline. But don’t assume it works for every Asics model. The Gel-Cumulus runs longer than the Gel-Nimbus. The Kayano is tighter in the heel than the Gel-Quantum.

Think of it like car models. A Honda Civic and a Toyota Corolla are both compact sedans. But you don’t assume the seat size is the same. You sit in each one.

Final rule: trust your foot, not the label

The number on the shoe box is just a starting point. Your foot is the final judge. When you try on a shoe, make sure:

• Your longest toe has a thumbnail’s width of space in front - no more, no less.
• Your heel doesn’t slip when you walk.
• You can wiggle your toes side to side without pressure.
• The midfoot feels snug but not squeezed.

If you’re running in shoes that feel tight after 3 miles, you’re not “breaking them in.” You’re risking stress fractures, black toenails, or plantar fasciitis. Shoes don’t stretch enough to fix bad sizing.

Frequently Asked Questions